The top 4 are within the margin of error — their exact order is closer to a coin flip than a result.

#	Car↕	ELO↓	Matches↕
1🥇	2009 Lamborghini Gallardo Superleggera🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥇LamborghiniHighest-rated Lamborghini (of 5 rated)castexi	1469±32	59
2🥈	2004 Ford Mustang Mach 1🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥇FordHighest-rated Ford (of 99 rated)r3dact3d	1463±32	55
3🥉	2006 Dodge Viper SRT-10🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥇DodgeHighest-rated Dodge (of 20 rated)ggenocidee	1448±32	53
4	2005 Ford GT🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥈Ford2nd highest-rated Ford (of 99 rated)saleeeeeen	1437±32	61
5	2000 Chevrolet S-10 Xtremeoxles	1421±32	58
6	2002 Mazda RX-7 Bathurst R🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥈Mazda2nd highest-rated Mazda (of 37 rated)13bturbo_	1419±32	53
7	2009 Chevrolet Corvette Z06 (C6)ggenocidee	1418±32	53
8	2007 Chevrolet Corvette Z06🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnersimpanda.	1410±32	58
9	2007 Chevrolet Monte Carlo SS🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnerslocalbreadman	1380±32	62
10	2003 Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution VIII GSR🥈Mitsubishi2nd highest-rated Mitsubishi (of 13 rated)naustronaut	1379±32	59
11	2007 Chevrolet Corvette (C6)namija	1374±32	54
12	2005 Subaru WRX STI🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥇SubaruHighest-rated Subaru (of 19 rated)katavancore	1373±32	61
13	2008 Toyota Crown Majesta (UZS186)🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥉Toyota3rd highest-rated Toyota (of 52 rated)speediestcomic	1369±32	50
14	2008 Ford Crown Victoria Police Interceptor🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnerssmokycountylogan	1367±32	58
15	2000 Chevrolet Corvette🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersdefromation	1365±32	66
16	2007 Holden Commodore VE SSV🥈1 runner-up finish — see the Hall of Winners🥇HoldenHighest-rated Holden (of 4 rated)woodsy104	1361±32	54
17	2008 Chevrolet HHR SS Manualsteadyrhombus	1345±32	53
18	2006 BMW M3🥉BMW3rd highest-rated BMW (of 30 rated)wasianfriedrice	1343±32	62
19	2001 Honda Acty🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥇HondaHighest-rated Honda (of 30 rated)joshandr34	1343±32	52
20	2007 Ford Falcon XR6 Turbo Utejimsbarraswaps	1335±32	59
21	2007 Ford Mustang GT🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersroot.beer0	1333±32	58
22	2004 Pontiac Grand Prix GTP Comp Gcmrn32	1329±32	57
23	2005 Pontiac GTObudthatsweiser	1325±32	60
24	2006 Nissan 350Z Touringzuizui	1316±32	60
25	2007 Subaru Impreza WRX Wagon🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥈Subaru2nd highest-rated Subaru (of 19 rated)crypted8143	1314±32	52
26	2008 Mazda RX-8 40th Anniversary Edition (397/400)killermanjaro	1311±32	58
27	2008 Mercedes-Benz S63 AMG🥈Mercedes-Benz2nd highest-rated Mercedes-Benz (of 17 rated)blizzies	1311±32	56
28	2003 Chevrolet Corvette Z06sakv3	1310±32	64
29	2001 Porsche Boxsterbongwater_bojack	1310±32	55
30	2009 Pontiac G8 GTZeta	1307±32	58
31	2003 Subaru WRX🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥉Subaru3rd highest-rated Subaru (of 19 rated)mr.eaturazz	1299±32	54
32	2009 Audi R8fluctus_faciunt	1297±32	58
33	2008 Chevrolet HHR SSjerrythekushman	1296±32	59
34	2004 Subaru Forester XTstubaru	1295±32	57
35	2006 Pontiac GTOjusth3ll	1295±32	53
36	2001 Thomas School Busbongwater_bojack	1291±32	55
37	2001 Lexus IS 300🥈Lexus2nd highest-rated Lexus (of 10 rated)lexusis300guy	1288±32	60
38	2005 Ford Falcon Ute MkII🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersuntrusteduser1	1286±32	52
39	2002 Volkswagen Jetta 1.8Tautumnstorm	1286±34	38
40	2000 Pontiac Firebird W68hotrod.bozo	1284±32	55
41	2004 Subaru Forester STI (SG9)dysicle	1282±32	55
42	2002 BMW 530i M Sportlinusstan	1281±32	60
43	2005 Mercedes-Benz C55 AMGunclebenz	1276±38	31
44	2002 Subaru Impreza WRXglonkfpv	1268±32	59
45	2009 Volkswagen Passat R36yourlocallosertm	1262±32	59
46	2004 Saturn Ion Redlinecaving1	1261±32	54
47	2002 Mercedes-Benz SLK 230 Kompressor (R170 Facelift)sayzohannibal	1259±32	61
48	2008 Volkswagen Golf R32slowasfk	1254±32	58
49	2006 Mercedes-Benz CLK 500illilliiiiiilli	1252±32	57
50	2008 MINI Cooper S🥇MINIHighest-rated MINI (of 4 rated)boosted.mini	1247±32	56