The top 2 are within the margin of error — their exact order is closer to a coin flip than a result.

#	Car↕	ELO↓	Matches↕
1🥇	1999 Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution V Rally Sport🥇MitsubishiHighest-rated Mitsubishi (of 13 rated)silentscone	1473±32	52
2🥈	1992 Toyota Supra Turbo🥇ToyotaHighest-rated Toyota (of 52 rated)92supra	1441±32	54
3🥉	1994 Nissan Skyline GT-R🥇NissanHighest-rated Nissan (of 23 rated)sea.brisket	1424±32	54
4	1998 Nissan Skyline R34 GTT Coupe🥈Nissan2nd highest-rated Nissan (of 23 rated)gansam	1418±32	57
5	1992 Nissan Skyline GTS-t Type M (R32)🥉Nissan3rd highest-rated Nissan (of 23 rated)jrodt	1417±32	53
6	1991 Nissan Skyline GT-R (R32)🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnerszuizui	1402±32	61
7	1996 BMW 750iL Security (E38)🥉1 third place — see the Hall of Winners🥇BMWHighest-rated BMW (of 30 rated)lukassnake2	1386±32	55
8	1991 Volvo 740SE🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥇VolvoHighest-rated Volvo (of 11 rated)corivus	1385±32	54
9	1990 Nissan Skyline GT-R (R32)cheeseballl	1385±32	53
10	1998 Nissan Skyline Sedan (R34)🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnerstherealconfox	1376±32	55
11	1998 BMW 328i (E36)🥈BMW2nd highest-rated BMW (of 30 rated)lukassnake2	1373±32	56
12	1997 Stewart & Stevenson M1078 LMTVtoyotataco	1370±32	53
13	1996 Nissan Cedricduckmint	1358±32	55
14	1994 Toyota Celica GT Four WRC🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners8hachiroku6	1353±32	55
15	1999 Toyota Century GZG50🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersexcalibur712	1351±32	52
16	1993 Toyota MR2train_cody	1350±32	58
17	1994 Pontiac Firebirddieselwitch	1348±32	60
18	1992 Volkswagen Cabriolet🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥇VolkswagenHighest-rated Volkswagen (of 35 rated)slowasfk	1345±32	55
19	1991 Mitsubishi Eclipse GSX🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersraymfnlit	1342±32	68
20	1996 Honda Integra Type R (DC2)🥈Honda2nd highest-rated Honda (of 30 rated)mave7457	1342±32	59
21	1991 Chevrolet Camaro Z28.just.ace.	1335±32	53
22	1994 Nissan 300ZXgorillaz.	1334±32	61
23	1992 Mazda MX-5 Miata🥉Mazda3rd highest-rated Mazda (of 37 rated)luk38609	1329±32	54
24	1990 Chevrolet Corvette🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnerssir_spanky_the_third	1324±32	54
25	1992 Toyota MR2 (SW20)hasbullabbg	1318±37	33
26	1993 Mazda MX-5 Miata🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnershaunter812_2	1310±32	57
27	1996 Ford Mustang Mystic Cobrasaleeeeeen	1308±32	51
28	1997 Mazda MX-5 Miatana8miata	1302±32	58
29	1991 Ford Ranger SuperCab🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersgooberkiller3000	1299±32	61
30	1999 Honda Civic Type R (EK9)🥉Honda3rd highest-rated Honda (of 30 rated)jku_aaron03	1298±32	51
31	1991 Mazda MX-5 Miata🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnershuayras	1295±32	59
32	1997 Mitsubishi Miragecoltze	1294±32	59
33	1991 Mazda MX-5 Miata Convertiblehappymiata12	1294±32	54
34	1992 Honda CRX Del Solatr.veyra	1280±32	58
35	1995 Mazda MX-5 Miatahoot13	1279±32	55
36	1993 Honda CRX Del Sol Mugenatr.veyra	1272±32	53
37	1995 Toyota Crown Royal Saloond.vercher	1272±32	52
38	1998 Subaru Impreza WRX STi🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnershuh8570	1269±32	57
39	1991 Jeep Cherokee Briarwood🥇JeepHighest-rated Jeep (of 8 rated)36393e.	1269±32	55
40	1992 Nissan Gloriabobross4882	1268±32	53
41	1997 Toyota Crown Royal Touringbaronvonteapot	1267±32	58
42	1993 Suzuki Jimny (JA11V)🥈1 runner-up finish — see the Hall of Winners🥇SuzukiHighest-rated Suzuki (of 6 rated)tastyechos	1267±35	37
43	1999 Porsche 911 (996.1)palmergoesfast	1266±32	59
44	1992 Chevrolet Corvettejerrythekushman	1263±32	54
45	1990 Toyota Land Cruiserstayted	1261±32	62
46	1994 Mazda MX-5 Miatabuzzaldrin	1261±32	56
47	1998 Toyota Altezza RS200 Z Editionaltezza_nikku	1257±32	61
48	1990 Eunos Roadstertobesmiata	1255±32	62
49	1990 Audi 80 (B3)businessfish69	1253±32	50
50	1999 Ford Crown Victoria Police Interceptoruss_sims	1251±32	58