The top 4 are within the margin of error — their exact order is closer to a coin flip than a result.

#	Car↕	ELO↓	Matches↕
1🥇	1986 Pontiac Fiero GT🥇PontiacHighest-rated Pontiac (of 16 rated)daydaylus	1452±32	62
2🥈	1980 Chevrolet Camaro Z/28🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥉Chevrolet3rd highest-rated Chevrolet (of 76 rated)el_micro3960	1432±32	67
3🥉	1981 Pontiac Firebird Turbo T/A🥈Pontiac2nd highest-rated Pontiac (of 16 rated)jwalk32	1432±32	57
4	1986 Toyota Corolla GT-S🥈Toyota2nd highest-rated Toyota (of 52 rated)_miyamoto	1425±32	55
5	1984 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnersleapdaycodyyy	1413±32	57
6	1988 Ford Mustang (Fox Body)🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥉Ford3rd highest-rated Ford (of 99 rated)007.jared	1401±32	60
7	1989 Chevrolet Corvette (C4)drhazey	1397±32	56
8	1989 Nissan Skyline GTS-t Type M (R32)🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnerskiiikoshi	1384±32	62
9	1989 Nissan Skyline GTS-t (R32)🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersthetruenathaniel	1366±32	58
10	1987 Toyota Corolla Levin Coupe (AE86)🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnerssoul6970	1361±32	57
11	1981 Ferrari 308 GTSi QV Euro Spec🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnerslimitedliabilites	1359±32	62
12	1986 Chevrolet Camaro IROC-Zjetpacktech	1344±32	55
13	1982 Datsun 280ZX🥇DatsunHighest-rated Datsun (of 3 rated)spurtonian	1338±32	57
14	1988 Toyota Supra (A70)🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnerssaucy_salad05	1322±32	61
15	1982 ZAZ Zaporozhets 968M🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersrubytuby	1321±32	63
16	1982 Datsun 280ZX Turbocarl.the.communist	1319±149	8
17	1983 Mazda RX-7 GSeastman51	1315±32	56
18	1984 Mercedes-Benz 300SD🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥇Mercedes-BenzHighest-rated Mercedes-Benz (of 17 rated)bongwater_bojack	1312±32	57
19	1988 Nissan 300ZX (Z31)vegaxwof	1310±32	56
20	1980 Mercedes-Benz 300SD (W116)beanoblub	1301±32	56
21	1989 Ford Mustang LX (Foxbody)wilmadictfit	1300±32	57
22	1988 BMW 316 (E30)🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersadekino	1297±32	51
23	1985 Dodge D100 Customlusifr	1292±32	56
24	1988 Pontiac Fiero Formuladaydaylus	1291±32	61
25	1988 Pontiac Trans Am GTAnikodemos.exe	1284±32	58
26	1989 Toyota Supradarkninja143186	1283±32	63
27	1988 Toyota 4Runner🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersjasedrivesslw	1278±32	54
28	1984 Volvo 240 GL🥈Volvo2nd highest-rated Volvo (of 11 rated)that80shonda	1273±32	54
29	1984 Alfa Romeo Giulietta🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersvlogenater	1269±32	57
30	1981 Chevrolet Camaro🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnerscorsond	1268±32	60
31	1983 Dodge Diplomatkxllswitch	1260±32	55
32	1985 Mazda RX-7 GS (FB)kitnxi	1258±32	59
33	1988 Chevrolet Camaro RSnotabody	1253±32	66
34	1988 Chevrolet S-10 Blazerworkhand16	1251±32	61
35	1980 Chevrolet C10 Silveradoplexafit	1251±32	52
36	1987 Volvo 245DLkieransudo_g4	1241±32	54
37	1989 Mazda B2200vivid8103	1239±32	56
38	1989 Chevrolet Camarojetpacktech	1238±32	58
39	1989 Volvo 240 (244)🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnerstalexandro	1237±32	55
40	1985 BMW 325e (E30)fpk8__	1234±32	59
41	1989 Volvo 740 GLhadpen	1234±34	39
42	1987 Chevrolet P30docplayz	1232±32	56
43	1989 Toyota Supratoyotally	1226±32	52
44	1980 AMC Eagle Limited Wagonbussin.buses1021	1223±32	58
45	1983 Toyota Cressidayacobino	1222±32	60
46	1981 Volkswagen Rabbit Pickup (Caddy in global market)vastlp1210636	1213±32	60
47	1989 Mazda MX-5 Miatamuddylemonade	1213±32	59
48	1983 Ford F-100matt_c1	1211±33	40
49	1986 Jeep Grand Wagoneer🥉Jeep3rd highest-rated Jeep (of 8 rated)jacksparrow1744	1210±32	59
50	1987 Chevrolet Chevette L Serie IIIjoslaleb_	1210±32	53