The top 4 are within the margin of error — their exact order is closer to a coin flip than a result.

#	Car↕	ELO↓	Matches↕
1🥇	1975 Mazda RX-4🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winners🥇MazdaHighest-rated Mazda (of 37 rated)13bturbo_	1431±32	57
2🥈	1972 Chevrolet Novascarecrow_bouncer	1412±32	56
3🥉	1971 Plymouth Cuda🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnersgoddl17	1409±33	42
4	1972 Buick GS455🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥇BuickHighest-rated Buick (of 4 rated)wolfiwaldfee	1401±32	57
5	1971 Ford Mustang Coupe🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnerslusifr	1374±32	57
6	1974 AMC Gremlin🥇AMCHighest-rated AMC (of 3 rated)limitinghalo	1371±32	55
7	1973 Toyota Corolla KE30🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersstayted	1358±32	62
8	1972 Chevrolet Nova🥈1 runner-up finish (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnerskawasaki7562	1353±32	55
9	1972 AMC Javelin-AMXchrisx.	1339±32	56
10	1970 Chevrolet Malibu_kanseidorifto	1338±32	53
11	1973 GMC Sprint🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winners🥇GMCHighest-rated GMC (of 4 rated)naginato	1336±32	56
12	1972 Chevrolet C10butthole15	1321±32	57
13	1974 Volkswagen 412🥈Volkswagen2nd highest-rated Volkswagen (of 35 rated)voidsmith	1319±32	60
14	1971 Dodge Demonthe.wasp	1313±32	56
15	1972 Chevrolet C10🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersitsronnow	1309±32	56
16	1977 Ford F-100 Ranger XLT🥇1 win — see the Hall of Winnerslexusis300guy	1307±32	60
17	1976 Fiat 124 Spider 1800🥇FiatHighest-rated Fiat (of 5 rated)imdinonuggie	1303±32	57
18	1978 Chevrolet Cheyenne K5 Blazer64ih_scout	1300±32	56
19	1974 Chevrolet Cheyenne K10slidingbolt223	1297±32	56
20	1979 MG Midgetdianetmotors	1297±32	53
21	1973 Volkswagen Käfer 1303🥉Volkswagen3rd highest-rated Volkswagen (of 35 rated)dannydeyeeeto	1291±32	56
22	1971 Chevrolet Monte Carloamstel508	1287±32	58
23	1977 Chevrolet Corvettevivid8103	1284±32	56
24	1977 Ford LTDcorsond	1275±32	57
25	1974 International Loadstar 1800🥇InternationalHighest-rated International (of 3 rated)bob_4	1272±32	55
26	1971 Volkswagen Karmann Ghia Cabrioletmalcomtodd	1266±32	51
27	1975 Ford LTD Landauvivid8103	1253±32	58
28	1979 Ford F-150 4x4🥉1 third place (1 inferred from all-time ELO — can still move) — see the Hall of Winnersdevin3471	1248±32	58
29	1979 Chevrolet Camarovivid8103	1244±32	58
30	1976 Massey Ferguson 1155massey2640	1241±32	58
31	1979 Audi 80 (B2)mr.fazekas	1233±32	55
32	1973 Oldsmobile Hurst/Oldsnapalmcobra	1222±32	60
33	1976 Ford Thunderbirdmassey2640	1216±32	59
34	1977 Ford Granadakitschular	1199±32	56
35	1978 Ford Thunderbirdstentarvo	1196±32	59
36	1974 Plymouth Valiantbuddyboiryebred	1185±32	45
37	1978 Fiat 127frankaphone	1178±32	56
38	1971 Ford Maverick Grabberlusifr	1178±32	53
39	1975 Dodge D100vivid8103	1157±32	55
40	1976 Ford Courierringobiggins2	1130±32	52